Friday, 20 July 2012

Indian prejudice against psychiatric diseases


Prejudice against diseases and handicaps have existed since ancient times when both physical and non-physical illnesses were considered as a “punishment” for some “sin” committed by the afflicted. Even today, though we mostly do not have any prejudice against the physically manifested illnesses but the society as a whole still looks down upon people seeking psychiatric help.


People here in India, still find it silly for someone taking pills for psychiatric disease. Any kind of psychiatric disease = crazy for us Indians.  'Why do you behave this way? Stop behaving this way and everything will be alright.' But what most of us do not know is that our behavior is a complex entity. It involves an electrochemical pathway that can sometimes hobble for many different reasons and then people have no control over functional or psychological aspects of their behavior. Some people are helped by diet and exercise, some are helped by meditation and some by medication. Really, who are we to judge?

 In our country, it is not uncommon for us to see mentally ill beggars on the streets. Most of us fear them and we shun them as best as we can. Even a friend or a relative who is mentally unstable, we would rather avoid them than get them proper diagnosis and medication- that would be like making them 'officially' crazy.

How are we so prejudiced? My personal opinion is that these prejudices form early on in our lives, in the first twenty years to be more precise. Let’s talk from childhood first. Children make jokes on mental illnesses "he’s so stupid, seems like he’s just been released from some mental hospital”. If showing anger, they generally equate idiocy = crazy = mental = stupid in a manner that is subtle, childish and funny = easy to ignore. Such jokes are a normal part and parcel of our Indian upbringing but then there it is, children learn that only stupid and crazy people need to go to a psychiatrist or to a mental institution and that it is to be made fun of.

In teenage, there are so many things that an immature youngster could be stressed about and there may always be a few youngsters who may seek psychiatric help or may want to. Due to the prejudices of the parents, those teenagers may not do so. The typical response of any parent, specially an Indian parent would be “Are you crazy, you need to see a psychiatrist?” "What will people say? that our son/daughter is crazy?" "Why are you so stressed?" "Your problems are nothing." " Don't be crazy." There we go again. Slowly our own prejudice has been formed. What the message here is- it is better to suffer than risk being called 'crazy'. 
Due to our close familial set up, we end up preserving within us, our parent's fears, beliefs and prejudices. And so the stigma lives on.



These prejudices further feed on the comical representation of mentally ill people in our cinema and television. In Bollywood, sometimes, the blatant degradation of mentally ill people is just surprising. How can these directors be so insensitive, a sane person might think. These movies seem childish, showing mentally ill people as dumb and stupid, fit to be made fun of. And since, art imitates life and life imitates art, our society finds these kinds of movies alright. Their mind tells them, yes, this is how these mentally sick people are and should be treated.

The mentality of people against mentally ill people is that they are suffering because of their own fault, just like in the past, it used to be a “punishment” for some “sin.” Depressed people are called selfish and if they seek psychiatric help, then crazy. Autistic people are crazy too, no matter if geniuses like Albert Einstein was one. The most common question that these “normal” people ask is “why are you unhappy? why cannot you behave normally?” why are you so obsessed?” You are being like this, so it is your fault. Don’t be like this. If you won’t be, everything will be alright.”

There is also some amount of prejudice connected with the practitioners who treat these mentally ill patients.It is the same prejudice that may be directed against you if are you associated with “losers.” Society looks down at these “losers” and those associated with them, also gets some amount of the people’s prejudices. Some people here may observe these practitioners keenly for the signs of any “craze” passed on by their patients. Not funny.

How to get of these prejudices? They will take time, a lot maybe, just like Rome, a great city, was not built in a day, so great & deep prejudices will also not go in a day. The best way to get rid of our prejudices would be: Awareness. We need more awareness and understanding towards the nature of mental diseases.Everybody, at some point of their lives, can be in deep pain and depression, so why not take help? Why should anyone suffer silently? Why should anyone put an end to this beautiful life? So many suicides happen just because people had no one to talk to.



The brain is our master organ which controls everything. It is not just the physiology of the brain which needs treatment but the beauty is, the brain is capable of healing itself and the rest of the body, simply by remaining full of happy positive thoughts. Synaptic plasticity, a recent break through in neuroscience, is all about the mechanisms by which the brain can mold itself. By means of different ways- whichever suits a person we could effect positive changes on our brain. This will also have an overall health benefit. We need more awareness regarding this. Research has proved that stress can deteriorate stomach ulcers . We know that getting angry easily and often can increase the blood pressure and thus lead to myocardial infarction (heart attack) or stroke or even both. Instead of spending thousands later on treating these effects, let us firstly treat the mind which is the cause. Is it not more intelligent?
In fact, if a person is mentally healthy, there are good chances that the person is physically healthy too. The mind, the thinking affects everything about the body. In this way we can say that Psychiatry and Psychology are the best of the curing sciences. They are the biggest healers and the most important in maintaining general health. We need to spread the knowledge and discuss things with other ignorant people. It is these ignorant people who make it difficult for the sufferers to live a normal life and it is these ignorant people who are the ones we can actually call “crazy”. 

Picture courtesy : 

http://boilingbloodwillcirculate.tumblr.com/

Monday, 16 July 2012

Guwahati Horror

It's hardly been a month since the Rumi Nath incident and we come across another mob attack in the heart of Assam, this time again on a defense less woman. The only difference this time is that the mob of 30 men had no ideological reason for attacking and stripping that 17 year old girl, on a busy road of Guwahati.

This incident has specifically shamed many Assamese who have known Assam to be a peaceful and safe place where women were given due respect. It is kind of shocking that when that girl was being subjected to that sort of cruelty, no one came to her rescue, despite it taking place in a swanky area of Guwahati City. Onlookers did their job of looking on, and someone, supposedly a cameraman from a news channel, filmed the whole scene for nearly 30 mins she struggled with the mob!

The video of the whole incident was being showed all over the news channels, like it is not a woman whose dignity is being ripped away, it's some sort of an object who is being destroyed. Though the filming of the video and the airing of the video, so blatantly, has been criticized by many, but the harm's done. The video will live on as a scar for this girl  forever and even if she tries to move on, this video, which is now even available on youtube, will haunt her for a long time to come.

But one good thing that came out of this video is that it helped to arrest the members of the mob. At this current moment that I am typing this, only 7 members have been arrested excluding Amarjyoti Kalita, the one who actually started it all. The police forces must do their utmost to find all of them and give them the strictest possible punishment and FILM it and AIR it on all the channels too. I am not talking about an eye for an eye judgement here but we need to make such men everywhere in India, aware that you just can't simply play with a woman and get away with it so easily. So in no case their sentences should be light!

And that beautiful little girl, unless she becomes very strong and can throw the past behind her totally, it would be difficult for her to come out of this. All prayers for her complete healing in this process. It is said, "You can never know how strong you are, unless being strong is your only choice." I hope she can dust herself off, find herself back again, love herself and move forward. Love and peace to her.

Wednesday, 11 July 2012

The curious case of Rumi Nath

Rumi Nath- an Assamese MLA and her list of troubles keep increasing. Within a week of facing an attempted rape and being badly beaten up along with her new husband,  now she faces a FRI which was filed against her by a Congress MLA for allegedly entering his residence and beating up his visitors.

                   Rumi Nath with her Husband at a press meet after the attack
                                                     (Courtesy : India today)

Surprisingly, even her badly bruised and battered face is also not evoking any sympathy for her from people in general. She is being seen as a criminal who rightly deserved the punishment meted out to her by an angry mob on the evening of 29th June 2012. Her horrendous and incorrigible crime list is: 

1. She married a Muslim
2. Converted to Islam 
3. Both 1 and 2 without divorcing her first husband officially.

People are screaming 'bigamy' 'bigamy', 'how dare she convert to islam?' ' why did she marry a muslim, is there a dearth of hindu men?' How dare she marry like that, without divorcing her first husband?' 'what kind of a mother she is?' 'what kind of a wife she is? '


                                                  Rumi Nath being ostracized by public
                                                (Courtesy : sevensisterspost.com)

She's also being called character-less, sinfully lusty and other worse things of the similar kind.

The words being pelted unto her, seem much like the stone pelting carried out under Taliban for an adulteress. There's no sympathy for her wounds. There are only beatings and killings for women of such kind in Taliban. (a most recent case can be read here http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/lookout/afghan-woman-execution-taliban-134305058.html).

But we are the "peace loving" "kind" "cultured" "sensitive" Indians who mask our "talibanism" very beautifully. We can assault a woman verbally and physically.Our villages may strip a woman and parade her but there won't be much sympathy, except maybe apparently- in our hearts of hearts, we would still be okay with it. It would seem like a well deserved punishment for a crime so heinous. We are not Taliban, we don't kill the adulteresses here openly, we only beat them up and assassinate their characters. Really, we are the good people, that's all we do.

Rumi Nath says she was not happy in her first marriage and her first husband was not giving her divorce. Anyone who's gone through a divorce in India, knows that how long divorce proceedings can take, specifically when the other party is not agreeing to grant you one.

This young lady was in need of support during the tough time she was going through in her marriage. Even if we believe that she was not going through a tough time but the simple fact would still remain that she was not happy with her husband, so she looked elsewhere for love and validation. Our innately traditional mentality can't accept a woman who deviates even slightly from the role of Sati, Savitri or Sita.The rigid thinking "A woman must seek happiness only from her husband and if she isn't happy with him, then it's her fault" was what Ms. Rumi Nath didn't cater to. She defied it and sought her own happiness- and she jumped at her chance to be happy. She found a man, who in her own words, "  doesn’t care whether or not I am married or have a child. Neither does he love me because I am an MLA. He looks at me just the way I am—Rumi Nath."

She changed her religion to Islam and her name to, Rebia Sultana to be with him. That is also a  necessary rule - to marry a Muslim you have to convert, at least on paper. She gave it all up in her quest for love and happiness.




Alas, her happiness invoked the innate Indian Taliban. And she paid whatever "little" price she had to "obviously" pay for her "sins". The media attention she is gathering after this attack on her, is again surprisingly, inciting more and more people against her. This shameful incident which seems "rightful" should at least make one thing clear to us- We are a bunch of hypocrites and our pretense makes us worse than Taliban- We are like wolves in sheep's clothes, unlike, the Taliban who does not give care about what the world says - being a wolf and they know it.

And that makes....us more dangerous.


.